Satire — no link to any official body

Sources

The quiz’s 8 “real” criteria and the source that establishes each one. Site rule: any criterion without a verifiable source is filed as satire.

A clerk operates a Hollerith tabulating machine while others work behind her.
A Hollerith tabulating machine in operation.

The real criteria

  1. French welfare fraud-risk score (CAF)

    According to source code (2010-2018) obtained by La Quadrature du Net, low income, minimum-income benefits or disability benefit received while working raise the “suspicion score” France’s family benefits agency (CAF) recomputes every month for each claimant.

    Source
    La Quadrature du Net, 2023
    See also
    Mediapart, 2026 : avis du Défenseur des droits
  2. Car insurance pricing by postcode

    In 2017, ProPublica and Consumer Reports found that some US car insurers charged up to 30% more, on average, in mostly non-white neighbourhoods than in white ones with similar risk. Some regulators dispute the method.

    Source
    ProPublica & Consumer Reports, 2017
  3. FICO credit score

    At FICO, the length of your credit history makes up 15% of the score. Without a credit account open for at least six months, you get no score at all: “you need credit to get credit”.

    Source
    myFICO
    See also
    myFICO : conditions minimales pour avoir un score
  4. COMPAS recidivism risk (US courts)

    This question appears in the COMPAS questionnaire, a tool used by US courts to estimate the risk of reoffending. In 2016, ProPublica showed it wrongly flagged Black defendants as future criminals almost twice as often as white defendants (the vendor disputes the analysis).

    Source
    ProPublica, « Machine Bias », 2016
    See also
    Questionnaire COMPAS (DocumentCloud)
  5. Watch time (TikTok “For You” algorithm)

    TikTok says so itself (2020): watching a longer video to the end is a “strong indicator” of interest and carries more weight in recommendations. The more you watch, the better the machine knows you.

    Source
    TikTok Newsroom, 2020
  6. Parcoursup local sorting algorithms (France)

    According to France’s Court of Audit (2020), up to 20% of selection panels for the most popular open-access courses used the applicant’s secondary school to rank candidates on Parcoursup in 2019. The ministry disputes this.

    Source
    Cour des comptes, 2020
    See also
    Défenseur des droits, décision 2019-021
  7. Uber rider and driver ratings

    Under Uber’s rules, drivers, riders and delivery people who fall below their city’s minimum average rating may lose access to all or part of the platform.

    Source
    Uber, règles de la communauté
  8. Automated CV screening

    According to Harvard Business School and Accenture (2021), almost half the companies surveyed weed out CVs with a “work gap”. Beyond six months, their recruiting software screens the CV out automatically, on that basis alone.

    Source
    Harvard Business School & Accenture, 2021
    See also
    Reuters, 2018 : l’outil expérimental d’Amazon pénalisait le mot « women’s »

The made-up criteria

These four criteria do not exist. They are there to make you doubt.

  • Lexical loyalty indexWhat do you call artificial intelligence?
  • Cognitive dispersion indexHow many browser tabs do you have open right now?
  • Machine courtesy coefficientDo you say “thank you” to chatbots?
  • Spelling rigour indexHave you ever left a typo in an official document?

The “SI” context

Further reading

  • According to France’s public algorithms observatory, 18 of 24 public algorithms fail to meet their publication duty.ODAP (in French)
  • Albania appointed Diella, an AI “minister”.BBC
Take the test